TradeDay vs Lucid
Two popular futures prop firms, compared on the numbers that decide whether you pass: target, drawdown, daily loss, consistency and minimum days.
TradeDay vs Lucid: 50K accounts side by side
| Firm · plan | Type | Target | Max drawdown | Drawdown type | Daily loss | Consistency | Min days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TradeDay Quick Pay · EOD | Evaluation | $3,000 | $2,000 | End-of-day trailing | None | 30% | 5 |
| TradeDay Quick Pay · Intraday | Evaluation | $3,000 | $2,000 | Intraday trailing | None | 30% | 5 |
| TradeDay Fast Pass | Evaluation | $3,000 | $2,000 | End-of-day trailing | None | 45% | 3 |
| Lucid LucidPro | Evaluation | $3,000 | $2,000 | End-of-day trailing | $1,200 (pauses the day) | None | 1 |
| Lucid LucidFlex | Evaluation | $3,000 | $2,000 | End-of-day trailing | None | 50% | 2 |
| Lucid LucidDaily | Evaluation | $3,000 | $2,000 | End-of-day trailing | $1,200 (pauses the day) | None | 1 |
| Lucid LucidDirect (instant) | Instant funding | $3,000 | $2,000 | End-of-day trailing | $1,200 (pauses the day) | 20% | None |
Rules checked November 2026 (tradeday.com) and November 2026 (lucidtrading.com). Confirm on each firm's website before buying. Not affiliated with either firm.
The short version
- Most room per dollar of target: TradeDay Quick Pay · EOD, with $2,000 of drawdown for a $3,000 target.
- No consistency rule: Lucid LucidPro, Lucid LucidDaily.
- No daily loss limit: TradeDay Quick Pay · EOD, TradeDay Quick Pay · Intraday, TradeDay Fast Pass, Lucid LucidFlex.
- End-of-day or static drawdown: TradeDay Quick Pay · EOD, TradeDay Fast Pass, Lucid LucidPro, Lucid LucidFlex, Lucid LucidDaily, Lucid LucidDirect (instant).
- Instant funding (no evaluation): Lucid LucidDirect (instant).
There is no universally "better" firm. A scalper who takes many small trades fits different rules than a swing-style NQ trader who waits for one A+ setup. The rule that fails most accounts is the drawdown, so start there: know exactly where your floor is before every trade. How trailing and end-of-day drawdown differ.
FAQ
Is TradeDay or Lucid easier to pass?
It depends on how you trade. Looking at 50K accounts, the most drawdown room relative to the target is TradeDay Quick Pay · EOD ($2,000 drawdown for a $3,000 target). Plans with no consistency rule: Lucid LucidPro, Lucid LucidDaily. If you tend to make your money in one or two big days, avoid strict consistency rules; if you sometimes give back profits intraday, prefer an end-of-day or static drawdown.
Which has the better drawdown, TradeDay or Lucid?
End-of-day or static drawdown is friendlier than intraday trailing because open profit doesn't drag your floor up. End-of-day/static options: TradeDay Quick Pay · EOD, TradeDay Fast Pass, Lucid LucidPro, Lucid LucidFlex, Lucid LucidDaily, Lucid LucidDirect (instant).
Do TradeDay and Lucid have daily loss limits?
Plans with no daily loss limit at 50K: TradeDay Quick Pay · EOD, TradeDay Quick Pay · Intraday, TradeDay Fast Pass, Lucid LucidFlex. Where a limit exists it usually pauses trading for the day, except on plans marked "fails account" in the table.
Stop guessing. Let PropPass watch the rules for you.
Pick your firm and account. PropPass tracks your drawdown, consistency and daily loss, warns you before red-folder news and tells you when to stand down. Free.